Samsung 870 EVO vs Crucial MX500: Which SATA SSD Wins
The Samsung 870 EVO and Crucial MX500 remain two of the best-known 2.5-inch SATA solid-state drives. Both use 3D TLC NAND, include onboard DRAM and target people upgrading an older desktop, laptop, game console or external drive. Their headline speeds are close enough that the buying decision usually comes down to price, endurance, warranty support and the type of workload involved.
For Australian buyers, availability can vary between Amazon Australia, JB Hi-Fi, Centre Com, Scorptec and smaller computer retailers. Prices also move sharply during EOFY sales, Black Friday and Click Frenzy, so a drive that looks expensive in Melbourne today may become excellent value in Brisbane or Perth a week later. This guide compares the two models in practical terms rather than relying only on sequential benchmark figures.
Core Hardware And Everyday Speed
Both drives use the SATA III interface, which has a practical ceiling of roughly 550 to 560MB/s for sequential transfers. The 870 EVO is rated for up to 560MB/s reads and 530MB/s writes, while the MX500 reaches approximately 560MB/s reads and 510MB/s writes, depending on capacity. Those figures are close enough that most users will not feel a dramatic difference when opening applications or browsing files.
The Samsung drive uses Samsung’s own controller and NAND, while Crucial’s MX500 uses a Silicon Motion controller with Micron 3D NAND. Both include DRAM, an important feature that helps maintain responsive file management and supports consistent performance compared with cheaper DRAM-less SATA SSDs. Windows boot times, office work and general multitasking should feel similarly quick on either model.
Large file transfers can expose a small advantage for the 870 EVO, especially when the source and destination drives are both fast. Once the dynamic SLC cache fills, however, sustained write speeds can drop on either SSD. The exact result depends on capacity, free space, file sizes and drive temperature, so advertised peak speed should not be treated as a guaranteed long-term transfer rate.
Endurance, Reliability And Warranty
Samsung rates the 870 EVO for a five-year limited warranty, with endurance increasing by capacity. The 1TB version, for example, is rated for 600TB written, while larger models receive higher total ratings. The MX500 also comes with a five-year limited warranty, although its official terabytes-written figures are generally lower at comparable capacities.
That difference matters most for heavy workloads such as daily video production, scratch-disk use, virtual machines or constant database activity. For a typical home computer, gaming laptop or family media system, either model should provide many years of service. Writing several hundred gigabytes every day is unusual for ordinary browsing, study and gaming.
Neither SSD should be filled to its final gigabyte. Leaving around 10 to 20 per cent free space gives the controller room for background housekeeping and can help preserve write performance. Buyers should also remember that endurance ratings describe warranty thresholds, not a guaranteed failure point or a precise prediction of lifespan.
Compatibility And Installation
The 870 EVO and MX500 are 2.5-inch, 7mm SATA drives, making them suitable for most older laptops and desktop bays. A desktop may need a 2.5-inch mounting bracket, while a laptop can require a spacer if its drive bay expects a thicker 9.5mm unit. The SATA data cable and power connector are standard, but an old desktop may need a spare cable or a bracket included in the retailer’s bundle.
Before buying, check whether the computer supports SATA III and whether its BIOS can detect a modern SSD. Older systems still benefit from either model even when limited to SATA II, although their maximum transfer rates will be lower. Cloning software can copy an existing Windows installation, but a clean installation is often preferable when moving from a cluttered hard disk.
Both drives work well as upgrades for older Windows PCs, Linux systems and many NAS devices. Compatibility with a PlayStation 4 or Xbox One can also improve loading times, although the console itself limits the overall experience. For a Mac, confirm the physical connector, operating-system support and whether the machine allows internal storage replacement before ordering.
Gaming, Streaming And Creative Work
For game loading, the difference between these SATA SSDs is usually small. A Samsung 870 EVO might complete a transfer or load a level slightly sooner in a benchmark, but frame rates are determined primarily by the graphics processor, processor and memory. Both drives are far quicker and more responsive than a mechanical hard disk, making either a worthwhile upgrade for an older gaming PC.
Large Steam, Epic Games or Xbox PC installations can benefit from a 1TB or 2TB model. A 500GB drive can become cramped after installing several modern games, Windows and creative applications. Australian broadband users downloading through the NBN may also prefer extra capacity because reinstalling a large library takes time and consumes data during busy periods.
Photo editors and video creators should consider their scratch-disk habits. Both SSDs are suitable for Lightroom catalogues, Photoshop work and 1080p editing, but sustained 4K footage transfers may expose cache slowdowns. A dedicated NVMe SSD is a better choice for high-volume professional production when the computer has an M.2 slot; these SATA models are more compelling for older systems without that interface.
Value And Australian Availability
The Crucial MX500 often becomes the value pick when its sale price is clearly below the 870 EVO. It is a mature, well-supported model with strong everyday performance and a five-year warranty. Samsung’s drive is attractive when the price gap is modest, particularly for buyers who value its slightly stronger rated endurance, broad software support and consistent reputation.
Check the exact capacity and seller before comparing listings. A discounted 870 EVO 500GB is not automatically better value than a 1TB MX500, and marketplace listings can occasionally confuse the 870 EVO with older Samsung generations. GST is generally included in Australian advertised prices, but shipping can alter the final cost for buyers outside Sydney, Melbourne or Brisbane.
Retailer reputation matters for warranty claims and authenticity. Keep the invoice, verify the model number in Samsung Magician or Crucial Storage Executive after installation, and avoid unusually cheap listings with vague product descriptions. For broader comparisons involving storage and other consumer electronics, Pckart’s SSD guides can help place these models alongside newer alternatives.
Choosing Between The Two Drives
For a quick buying decision, the Samsung 870 EVO makes the most sense when:
- Its price is close to the equivalent MX500
- The computer will handle frequent, heavy writes
- Samsung’s monitoring and cloning software is useful
- The buyer prefers a drive with higher rated endurance
The Crucial MX500 is a strong choice when:
- It is substantially cheaper at the same capacity
- The drive is intended for everyday computing or gaming
- A five-year warranty and DRAM cache are priorities
- The upgrade is for an older SATA-only laptop or desktop
Capacity should guide the final decision as much as brand. A 1TB SSD with sensible free space is usually a better experience than a faster-feeling 500GB drive that is nearly full. For a secondary game library, 2TB offers a comfortable balance, while a 500GB model remains suitable for a light office PC or basic laptop upgrade.
Overall, the 870 EVO is the safer premium choice when pricing is similar, while the MX500 delivers excellent value when discounted. Neither represents a poor purchase for a SATA upgrade; the best option is the one with the greater capacity, reliable local warranty and lower cost per usable terabyte.
Compare current Australian listings, confirm the correct 2.5-inch capacity and choose the model that fits the workload rather than paying extra for benchmark gains that may be difficult to notice.